Homemade Ketchup from Plums and Red Wine

This recipe for plum & zinfandel ketchup is inspired by The Dry Creek Valley. Made from local plums, zinfandel wine, and zinfandel vinegar, and spiced with star anise, everything about this condiment reminds me of Sonoma County, the place I call home.

A blogger trip to Sonoma County’s wine country was just the thing I needed to provide the final nudge to leave San Francisco. In May of 2012, I spent three glorious days at the Raford Inn in Healdsburg, CA. Eleven months later, our moving truck was packed, and we were on our way.

Since I was a girl, I’ve been captivated, enchanted, totally bewitched by Sonoma County. This place can take hold of someone and be stubborn in letting go.  The Pomo people have been here for at least 5,000 years- the very name of this place, Sonoma, is said to have come from the Pomo words for Earth Place (tso) and Village (noma). There are farmers and vintners who have been here for 5, 6 even 8 generations and there’s little question as to why they stay.

The Dry Creek AVA runs along a tributary of the Russian River (the very river I now live on) and is 16 miles x 2 miles.  If you’ve heard of Dry Creek Valley, then you’re probably thinking of their spectacular Zinfandels. Georges Bloc, of France, was the first vintner in the Dry Creek Valley, and when he planted there in 1833, it is thought that he planted Zinfandel grapes. It is no accident that those very grapes have dominated Dry Creek since the 1880s- Dry Creek’s terroir and climate make for some of the best Zins in the world.

On a recent blogger outing to the Dry Creek Valley (Mihilakawna, in Pomo in case you wondereed), I had the opportunity to drink, taste, smell, pair, and blend wines from the famous AVA.

Our day began at Fritz Underground Winery where we walked the gorgeous grounds, explored the cellars, and did a scent seminar. It’s always fascinating to see what notes people smell in wine and how the notes change as the wines change temperature and are exposed to air. I have an insanely strong sense of smell- which is a blessing when it comes to cooking and pairing wines but a curse when it comes to living with two pit bulls.

I’ll admit, I was quite skeptical when I learned we’d be doing a “soil tasting” at Mauritson. While I’m an adventurous eater, and have enjoyed “soil” in the molecular gastronomy world, I never even ate dirt as a child. The thought of starting a dirt-eating habit in my 30’s seemed unlikely, but I never say never. I was quite relieved that our soil-tasting consisted of smelling, touching, and comparing soils then tasting the wines that are grown in them. Mauritson knows its soil too, they’ve been growing on this land for nearly 175 years.

Our trip to Quivira was my second. Their grounds are modern yet rustic, beautiful, and boast lots of critters like pigs, bees, and chickens as well as abundant wildlife. Quivira is certified organic and biodynamic which means they use no chemical fertilizers, only organic pest control, and they make gorgeous compost tea by burying their compost underground.  Their organic gardens are friends to the grapes, beneficial insects, and soil, yet foe to the nasty pests which can destroy grapes. Quivira has been working hard to restore Dry Creek and to bring the salmon back. Oh, and did I mention how very nice they are?

Our final stop on our day-long tour was to Dutcher Crossing where we had a crash course in blending wines- specifically Zinfandel. This is the MOST fun I’ve ever had with wine (well, that I can write about here). Dutcher Crossing winemaker, Kerry Damskey absolutely knows his stuff. I absolutely love his passion for wine, his casual take on tasting, and also his wife Kitty.  Being a total nerd, I had so much fun making notes on the percentage of each wine, tasting, and tasting again until I had (what I thought was) a really tasty blend.

The owner of Dutcher Crossing, Debra, had us to her home for a lovely dinner which was almost entirely gluten free (yay). It was during dinner that our blends were judged in a blind tasting by a panel of winemakers from Dutcher Crossing, Amphora, Thumbprint, and Collier Falls . I was thrilled to learn that the judges agreed “instantaneously and unanimously” that I had indeed made a very tasty wine- the tastiest as a matter of fact. I went home with a huge prize package including some very very nice wine as well as two tickets to the Dry Creek Valley Passport Event.

Since May, I’ve opened a few amazing bottles of Dry Creek Valley Zinfandel and one outstanding Petit Verdot from Thumbprint. While each Zin has it’s own character, and I am particularly fond of zins, I am partial to those with rich dark plum flavors and a hint of clove and spice. When cooking with Zinfandel, I adore pairing it with plums, blackberries, spice, and sometimes even very dark chocolate with fruity acidic tones.

The idea for a plum ketchup came when I was getting ready to grill some sausages. We had wild boar, pheasant, and duck sausages from a local purveyor and each one paired beautifully with the ketchup- and don’t forget to pour a big glass of zin to accompany your meal.

I used juicy black plums from my local market, Food For Humans. You could also use Santa Rosa or Elephant Heart Plums. For a special treat, try this with locally foraged wild plums!

  • Ingredients for Homemade Plum Ketchup with Zinfandel

  • 2.5 lbs of ripe juicy plums, quartered and pitted
  • ½ cup Zinfandel
  • 2 tablespoons red wine vinegar (I used this Zinfandel Vinegar from Katz)
  • ½ cup of dark brown sugar (packed)
  • 1 piece star anise
  • 1 pinch ground clove
  • 1 cinnamon stick
  • ¼ teaspoon allspice
  • ½ teaspoon course sea salt plus more to taste
  • 2 teaspoons cayenne pepper (optional)
  • 4 cloves finely minced garlic


  • Instructions for Homemade Plum Ketchup with Zinfandel

  • In a heavy saucepan over medium high heat, bring all ingredients except garlic and cayenne to a boil. Lower heat to medium and cook at a simmer. Stir frequently, mashing plums as you go for 20 minutes or until the liquid is very thick and syrupy- verging on a jammy texure.
  • Allow to cool for 10 minutes, remove star anise and cinnamon stick and then blend in a high powered blender (I used the Ninja Mega Kitchen System) or food processor until completely smooth.
  • Return to the saucepan, adding garlic and cayenne. Cook on medium low, and keep at a bare simmer until the ketchup is as thick as (well) ketchup. Five to Ten minutes should be just about right.
  •  Pour into a glass mason jar and enjoy anywhere you’d enjoy ketchup or barbecue sauce.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

{ 16 comments… read them below or add one }

londonbakes July 10, 2013 at 5:24 AM

I love Sonoma, such a special place and this post was such a joy to read. Not to mention that ketchup sounds delicious!


Sabrina Modelle July 15, 2013 at 1:00 PM

Thank you. I love it here and the ketchup, well… you should try some. ;)


Crista July 10, 2013 at 7:48 AM

This is a fantastic post! Beautiful photos and I love the recipe!!!


Sabrina Modelle July 15, 2013 at 1:00 PM

Thank you so much, Crista!


bellacucinamaria July 12, 2013 at 5:30 PM

This is absolutely delicious. The only adjustment I made was to use sherry vinegar (I like it better than red wine) and scaled back the cayenne a bit. It's just divine. I made burgers tonight with herbs de provence and crushed marcona almonds and together they rocked!


The Tomato Tart July 15, 2013 at 12:59 PM

Yay! You made it? I\’m so glad you enjoyed it. I am going to make a second version with the wild plums I foraged last week!


Maria July 15, 2013 at 1:30 PM

Yes! I made hamburgers on Fri night with crushed marcona almonds and herbs de Provence, topped with cheddar and your plum ketchup. Amazing! I am a personal chef and today for one of the families I cook for I made a chicken burger, same seasoning: marconas and herbs d’ p … and some of it to use. I will let you know the verdict!! ;)


The Tomato Tart July 15, 2013 at 2:21 PM

Awesome, Maria. I also used it to marinate and then roast chicken thighs. When the chicken was done, I made a pan sauce from the juices and more of the ketchup. Highly recommended.
PS, your burgers sound fabulous.


Maria July 17, 2013 at 2:43 PM

They loved them! I am def going to try it with the chicken. The recipe makes a nice amount. BTW .. I noticed yellow plums at the farmers market this weekend. I bet they would work really well too and the color would be pretty!

Amanda Paa July 13, 2013 at 7:36 PM

Such gorgeous photography. I too am in love with the dry creek valley and we are actually coming out next week. Seghesio and Alexander Valley Vineyards are on my list because i have yet to visit and they are some of my favorites, but these look great too. Which would you suggest if you had to pick just one?


Sabrina Modelle July 15, 2013 at 1:02 PM

I absolutely love Dutcher Crossing's wine and Quivira's grounds. Also (not on this list) is Truett Hurst- one of my favorite wineries ever.


Hilary A July 26, 2013 at 7:40 PM

This looks amazing! Would I want to hot-water bath can this or keep it in the fridge?


The Tomato Tart July 28, 2013 at 12:30 PM

I don\’t think there\’s enough acid for safe canning on this one. I just keep mine in the fridge and it doesn\’t last all that long. I love it as a marinade for chicken and for tofu too!


Molly August 15, 2013 at 5:17 AM

What an interesting recipe, and beautiful results! Love your initial interpretation of "soil tasting"—I definitely would've thought it involved tasting dirt, too. I've never been to a vineyard but this post makes it sound so fun.


Ally September 8, 2013 at 12:13 PM

Mmm, that sounds good! I just made some plum jam yesterday and the smell of plums is still lingering in the house. I love it. Plum ketchup sound lovely and decadent!


Sabrina Modelle July 18, 2013 at 10:49 AM

I've been foraging wild yellow plums. It's on my agenda to make the ketchup with those and a dry rosé!


Leave a Comment

{ 3 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: